The Balloon by Donald Barthelme

Up.

Donald Barthelme’s The Balloon is like a piece of abstract art that refuses to explain itself—and that’s exactly the point. Barthelme, ever the postmodern trickster, thrives on teasing out our need for tidy meanings. In this short story, he inflates (pun intended) a playful meditation on how art is represented, perceived, and, ultimately, misunderstood in a world obsessed with pinning things down.

The premise is as delightfully odd as it gets: a giant balloon appears over New York City. That’s it. No backstory, no rational explanation. Naturally, the city’s inhabitants do what humans do best—overanalyze. They poke, prod, and project their own interpretations onto this floating enigma. Is it a political statement? A personal outcry? A metaphor for...something? Ultimately, even language and form dissolves into nonsensical jargon. And as the narrator casually points out early on, trying to decipher the “meaning” of this balloon is not just futile—it’s missing the point entirely:

“There was a certain amount of initial argumentation about the ‘meaning’ of the balloon, this subsided, because we learned not to insist on meanings and they are rarely even looked for now, except in cases involving the simplest, safest, phenomena.”

In other words, relax. Stop trying to overthink it. Or do. Barthelme doesn’t care, and that’s what makes it great.

What unfolds isn’t a story in the conventional sense—there’s no plot, no character arc. Instead, we get a patchwork of reactions and impressions from the city’s residents, filtered through a sly, shifting narrative voice that doubles as a cheeky commentary on the artist-audience relationship. The narrator, an artist figure, plays with the reader’s uncontrollable urge (consciously or subconsciously) to piece things together, only to remind us how futile that process can be.

And then, there’s the wonderful arbitrary ending. The final paragraph epitomizes everything that I love about Barthelme's writing! Without spoiling it, let’s just say he pulls the rug out from under us in spectacular fashion. What seemed like an artistic exercise in ambiguity all along suddenly reveals its “true” purpose. The balloon wasn’t some grand symbol or profound statement. Nope, it was just there, because...reasons.

This is Barthelme at his best, poking fun at our literary pretensions while crafting something that’s simultaneously whimsical and deeply philosophical. The Balloon is a playful reminder that good art doesn’t have to mean anything—and sometimes, it’s better that way. Like the titular balloon, it floats beyond our grasp, offering not answers but endless possibilities. So, let it drift. And enjoy the view.