I can see why people often compare Saki (a.k.a. H.H Munroe) to O. Henry since their writing style feels similar along with a shared love for the twist ending, but I personally lean more toward the latter. The Open Window is still an enjoyable story, especially in how tightly it’s constructed. It does a lot in a very small amount of space.
It’s also tricky to talk about without spoiling it, since everything hinges on that final moment. If that doesn't bother you, please read on.
What’s worth paying attention to, though, are the subtle shifts in tone when Vera, the young girl, is talking to Framton Nuttel (a wonderfully odd name, by the way) about why the large parlor windows are always kept open in the house. Her manner is calm, polite, and sincere. Exactly the sort of behavior that social convention tells Framton he should trust without question.
Framton’s already anxious and socially awkward, which makes him the perfect target. He’s too polite to challenge her story and far too trusting of appearances. Saki has a lot of fun exposing how easily good manners and surface-level civility can be weaponized. The deception clearly works because Vera is clever but also because the adults around her are conditioned to believe what’s presented to them calmly and confidently. By the time the story snaps shut, the joke isn’t only on Framton but the reader as well. The cheeky and humorous final line has a slightly wicked bite: "Romance at short notice was her speciality." This is a neat reframing device of the entire story in retrospect, further highlighting the dangers of misplaced trust and rigid social conventions.
No comments:
Post a Comment